Thursday, 20 April 2017

At last, some action!

I have become aware recently that this blog is lacking in battle reports, mostly focused upon what's on the painting table as I tend to churn out a fair bit of stuff each week. Whilst I'm still enjoying building and painting 15mm Flames of War models and figures, my enthusiasm for wargaming generally has declined over recent months. A couple of weeks back for example I set up a nice Normandy themed table that featured hedgerow lined roads and fields, standing cropfields, woods and a central village containing no less than ten 4Ground houses.  I sorted out a couple of small forces, stood back and looked at the table and realised that as realistic as it looked, from a wargame point of view it was going to be almost impossible to play on. There was little or no space to maneuver a formation of tanks, hardly any open sight lines and the hedgerows were going to make both movement and shooting difficult. The models went back in the boxes and I started to think about how to simplify the terrain.

For this game the table will be far more open, with far fewer hedgerows lining the roads, just two wood templates and only a few buildings. This is a more traditional approach to table top terrain I think, far more practical if less realistic, with each piece of terrain clearly defined according to FoW V4 rules. The standing crop fields for example are no longer contained within tall hedges as before, but still offer concealment to troops within it. The outskirts of the small village are now more open and sight lines are also more open, offering opportunities for longer range shooting. Having got over the temptation to cram everything onto the table I now feel I can run through a solo game to get to grips with V4.

FoW 4 does make some changes to the previous version, much has been simplified to speed up play, hit allocation is one example where you now simply declare your target team within a platoon and that team takes the first hit with other hits allocated to next nearest etc. The dreaded Bogging checks become Cross checks with a slightly better chance of passing, and formation commanders can issue a 'Follow Me' order to gain an additional 4" of movement if within 6" of a unit. Aircraft rules have been bought more into line with the game with streamlined shooting, fighter interception and flack rules. The assault rules also look to have been tidied up.

So with the table set up as below my youngest daughter diced for sides and placed a couple of objectives for the game. Forces are two late war armour based armies with infantry and artillery support. I'll roll for air support each turn and will be using my Typhoon & ME 262 models, although I'll use the 'Stuka' stats for the latter until I can find something more suitable!

US to move first, it's a simple straight encounter game across a fairly open field, the tall hedgerows remain in the box, the standing crops offer concealment and soft cover, the ploughed fields offer soft cover, the woods are also soft cover and require a cross check to enter, and the railway embankment also requires a cross check to move across. Buildings of course are hard cover, I simply had to get the church on the table although the model  will be much enhanced once rubble sections have been produced as per those made by James at The Mad Tin Hatter blog, well worth checking out, a great idea.

Images show the table before move 1, Dining room booked until Sunday so I can leave it set up and take my time. All terrain items from my collection are as follows:

  • Baseboards by Total Systems Scenic 'space saver' boards. I resisted the urge to add hills at this time although I do have a lot of matching hill pieces.
  • Rural roads, cobbled roads & rail sections are 'Battlefield in a Box' range.
  • Buildings by 4Ground MDF kits.
  • Trees and wood templates by S&A Scenics.
  • Fields made from door mat and carpet tiles recoloured and flocked.
  • Wall sections by 'Small Terrain Miniature Scenery' (eBay)









Battle report and pictures will follow, possibly broken down into a couple of posts.

Edited to add a few deployment shots, Turn 1. Deployment is difficult when playing solo, so both sides move onto the table and the shooting can begin in Turn 2. Things look pretty linear but that quickly break down as the game develops. The Germans are massing on the right for an attack on the village, StuG's advancing supported by the Panzer Grenadier platoons with mortar sections. On the Allied right the M10 tank destroyers have advanced in open ground, their recce advancing to find targets while Stuart light tanks move up to protect their exposed right flank. Panzer IV's move toward the woods, they will make short work of those Stuarts if they can get through the woods quickly. Sherman's advance across the entire front. 















13 comments:

  1. Looks good.... I think a lot of the guys who actually fought in Normandy would agree with your statement "it was going to be almost impossible to play on".. :o)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Absolutely Steve..... 'Hedgerow Hell'.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Looking forward to an AAR and agree with your observations that re terrain, balance is needed between function and realism.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Norm, once again my lack of enthusiasm got the better of me, please see my next post!

      Delete
  4. Looks excellent - 15mm gives a fine big field too - agree with comments on scenery - easy to get bogged down. This is about right - you can see clearly what's what, the appearance is attractive and yet there's space to develop the game.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Tony, I have been forced into a major re think! The table remained up for 3 days during which time I just could not find the enthusiasm to play even a single turn. I enjoyed seeing it all set up it's clear that FoW is not going to work as a solo game for me. Next post will explain things a little better. Maybe it's my age, but I'm finding it harder to retain and enjoy complex rule sets thesedays.

      Delete
  5. In V3, bocage was a nightmare to play through. Made for really slow boring games where almost exclusively the defender would win.

    Your set up looks like it'd make for a fun game Lee. Looking forward to reading the report!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Great looking Table Lee, looking forward to reading the battle rep!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Great looking setup, it's difficult to strike a balance between realism and playable.
    Best Iain

    ReplyDelete
  8. Your terrain, tanks and wee men are absolutely first class, 'Lee. You have an artists eye for layout, too, me thinks. A very pleasing composition, and eminently playable.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you Matt,
      As said above I enjoyed laying it all out but just could not find enthusiasm to actually play the game! Not sure why, but I'm giving the matter some thought and a couple of surprises for my next post.

      Delete